Papers › Do AI chatbots find what experts would? Effects of model, user role, and sample size...

Do AI chatbots find what experts would? Effects of model, user role, and sample size on study retrieval for medical questions

13 Aug 2026arXiv:2608.13786added by Syntology

Qingfang Liu, Qiao Jin, Joe D. Menke, Thorsten Kahnt, Zhiyong Lu

Title, abstract, authors and date from arXiv's metadata (CC0); this paper is not in the Papers with Code archive (frozen 2025-07-28).

Large language model (LLM) chatbots are increasingly used to answer clinical questions with citations to relevant clinical studies. Prior research has largely focused on citation fabrication, leaving a gap in evaluating the quality of retrieved studies and the factors driving their selection. In this study, we evaluated three general-purpose LLM chatbots: Claude Sonnet 5, Gemini 3.1 Pro, and ChatGPT GPT-5.5. We prompted the models with clinical questions adapted from 20 review questions in Issues 6 and 7 of the 2026 Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, simulating patient, clinician, and evidence-synthesis researcher roles. Each chatbot was queried under each user role with four independent repetitions, yielding 720 responses. Each chatbot was asked to support its answers with primary clinical citations, which we benchmarked against the included and excluded study sets of the Cochrane reviews. On average, a chatbot response retrieved 39.2% ± 29.8% of Cochrane included studies, while citing 5.0% ± 9.4% of excluded studies. Recall of Cochrane included studies varied significantly by model and user role. ChatGPT achieved higher recall than Claude or Gemini (63.1% ± 29.5% vs. 37.0% ± 23.8% vs. 17.3% ± 13.1%; p=2.0×10⁻⁵). The researcher role yielded higher recall than the clinician or patient roles (42.8% ± 30.8% vs. 38.6% ± 28.9% vs. 36.1% ± 29.3%; p=2.0×10⁻⁵). Controlling for publication year, citations per year, and open-access status, sample size was the only independently significant predictor of retrieval (odds ratio 1.80 per 1-unit increase in log sample size, 95% CI 1.37-2.36, p=2.34×10⁻⁵). These findings suggest that while LLM chatbots can retrieve some studies identified by expert reviewers, their performance varies by model and user role, and they exhibit a bias toward clinical trials with larger sample sizes.

PaperPDFCode Syntology ran

In Syntology View this paper on Syntology, its page in Syntology's graph. That page adds which of its functions are also present in other papers' code Syntology holds, with dates, and its dated run record as JSON and a README badge. It also lists the repositories linked to the paper, the abstract and the calls for agents.

Open this paper in Syntology's Atlas, the map of the papers in Syntology's graph and their citations.

For agents, on Syntology's MCP service (how to connect):

Code

Syntology 31 code samples harvested from 1 repository linked to this paper: 25 ran (of which 0 constructed an object rather than computing a result; 3 with no instrument failure: 2 honoured, 1 violated, 0 with no contract checked; 22 where Syntology's instrument failed) · 6 unverified. Where Syntology's instrument failed: 22 where our contract draft was wrong; failures of Syntology's instrument, not of the code.

By repository: found in paper text by Syntology: 31 samples from 1 repository, 25 ran (3 with no instrument failure; 22 where Syntology's instrument failed). The run record, sample by sample. “Ran” means executed on a synthesized input, not that the code is correct or reproduces the paper.

Levels written on 2026-09-24 (UTC): the dates Syntology's graph wrote each sample's verification level, not when the code executed.

QingfangLiu/llm-evidence-retrieval-bias found in paper text by SyntologySyntology: 31 samples, 25 ran (22 instrument-failed) · 6 unverified report

Reachability, where shown, is from one Syntology probe window (2026-09-16 to 2026-09-18); repositories not probed show nothing. GitHub stars are not tracked.

Code Syntology ran Syntology

31 samples harvested: 25 ran (of which 0 constructed an object rather than computing a result; 3 with no instrument failure: 2 honoured, 1 violated, 0 with no contract checked; 22 where Syntology's instrument failed) · 6 unverified. “Where Syntology's instrument failed” counts failures of Syntology's instrument, not of the code. Syntology's record for this page last changed ; when this build read Syntology's graph is in the build record. That date is not when the samples ran.

2ran · honoured contract
1ran · violated contract
22ran · our draft was wrong
6unverified

Licence: 31 of the 31 samples are pointer only, meaning Syntology does not serve that copy's text. This page shows no code text for any sample; each one links to its file in the repository.

Harvested from QingfangLiu/llm-evidence-retrieval-bias. “Ran” means the sample executed on a synthesized input. It does not mean the output is correct, and nothing here reproduces the paper's results. A line beginning “fixture:” under a sample that ran gives the arguments Syntology's fixture called the sample with, each as name:type/rank/element kind (? where none was recorded), and the type of what the fixture's run returned, exactly as the harness recorded them; the arguments and the returned type were recorded by two separate runs of the same fixture. No output value is shown, and a returned type says nothing about whether the output was right. “Level recorded” gives the UTC date when Syntology's graph wrote the sample's verification level, not when the code executed; where the level was written before Syntology's graph kept that date, the row says “level recorded, date not recorded”. “Honoured” and “violated” refer to a contract Syntology drafted from the code itself. “Our draft was wrong” and “the contract check could not run” are failures of Syntology's instrument, not of the code: the sample ran on Syntology's synthesized input, and then the drafted contract did not describe it, or the check itself raised an error (RAISES), lacked a dependency (DEP_MISSING) or ran out of time (TIMEOUT); hover the label for which. A metamorphic tier, where shown, is evidence of the output's shape, not that the sample implements the method.

Each sample ends with its code_sha256. A sample's code_sha256 is Syntology's identity for that exact code. It is printed in full (16 hexadecimal characters for every sample in this build), and get_code(code_sha256="…") takes it exactly as printed. An agent calls it on Syntology's MCP service (how to connect); click an identity to copy that call.

Repository labels, per sample. official repository: The archive marks this repository official for the paper. named in the paper: The archive records that the paper mentions this repository; it is not marked official. community (archive-listed): In the archive's code links for this paper, not marked official and not recorded as mentioned in the paper. found in paper text by Syntology: Syntology found this repository in the paper's own text; whether it is the authors' implementation is not asserted. community: Not in the archive's code links for this paper; a community repository Syntology harvested. Samples are grouped by repository: a repository marked official first, then by how directly the repository is tied to the paper, then in the archive's order; never by how many ran. Licence labels name the repository's licence as recorded at harvest. “Pointer only” means Syntology does not serve that copy's text, for one of six reasons: no licence file was found; the licence was not identified; the licence is recorded as permissive but that copy's record is not marked cleared; the licence is outside the permissive list Syntology serves text under (MIT, Apache-2.0, BSD and similar); this paper's copy was not located, so its licence is not recorded; or this paper's copy is cleared, but the stored copy of the same code that Syntology serves is not. Some licences outside that list permit redistribution, such as WTFPL, and GPL-3.0 under its conditions; they are simply not on the list. Hover a licence label for the reason. File links open the file on GitHub at the default branch, which may have changed since the harvest.

A function or class name links to its page when the name occurs in the harvested code of at least 5 papers; the name is a string, not an identity. A census tag appears when Syntology's census ran implementations with that name on one shared input per bucket: it gives how many were compared, from how many papers, and how many distinct outputs they produced, and names this sample's bucket when this sample was one of them.

QingfangLiu/llm-evidence-retrieval-bias found in paper text by Syntology 31 samples, 25 ran (22 instrument-failed) · 6 unverified
calculate_mann_whitney_test demo/overlap_metrics.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · 2d0de3f9a753d906 · report fixture: signature sample_a:list/1/float, sample_b:list/1/float, label_a:str/0/str, label_b:str/0/str · returned dict · level recorded 2026-09-24
calculate_multi_set_jaccard demo/overlap_metrics.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · 0843b6bce84576ef · report fixture: signature study_sets:list/1/set · returned dict · level recorded 2026-09-24
calculate_replicate_consistency demo/overlap_metrics.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · 68c30d932a7949aa · report fixture: signature replicate_sets:list/1/set · returned dict · level recorded 2026-09-24
cell benchmark_tools/reference_indexing_schema.py ran · our draft was wrong fingerprinted no licence file found · pointer only · 25480657033da448 · report fixture: signature value:int/0/int · returned str · level recorded 2026-09-24
citation_identity_note reviews/CD000510/analyze_cd000510_roles.py ran · our draft was wrong fingerprinted no licence file found · pointer only · a15ecee30950237e · report fixture: signature entry:str/0/str, key:str/0/str · returned str · level recorded 2026-09-24
collect_review_pdfs benchmark_tools/cochrane_review_source.py ran · honoured contract no licence file found · pointer only · d5c2b8646741a30a · report fixture: signature paths:list/1/PosixPath · returned list · level recorded 2026-09-24
compact in 8 papers benchmark_tools/build_reference_indexing_from_cochrane_ris.py ran · our draft was wrong fingerprinted no licence file found · pointer only · cd382468e750cf17 · report fixture: signature value:str/0/str · returned str · level recorded 2026-09-24
compact in 8 papers benchmark_tools/reference_indexing_schema.py ran · our draft was wrong fingerprinted no licence file found · pointer only · 744acc2017757c05 · report fixture: signature value:str/0/str · returned str · level recorded 2026-09-24
dimension_summaries figures/make_paper_figures.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · 31ff80b0e0d7f9b7 · report fixture: signature demo_data:dict/0/? · returned dict · level recorded 2026-09-24
extract_claude_list reviews/CD001452/analyze_cd001452_roles.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · a504f8f552b1365c · report fixture: signature path:PosixPath/0/?, lines:list/1/str · returned list · level recorded 2026-09-24
extract_terminal_list reviews/CD007654/analyze_cd007654_roles.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · 274aeac953e50576 · report fixture: signature path:PosixPath/0/? · returned list · level recorded 2026-09-24
is_review_pdf_path benchmark_tools/cochrane_review_source.py ran · violated contract no licence file found · pointer only · c667163c27e05788 · report fixture: signature pdf:PosixPath/0/? · returned bool · level recorded 2026-09-24
last_heading_index reviews/CD001452/analyze_cd001452_roles.py ran · honoured contract no licence file found · pointer only · 9c02250cd6cbdd4a · report fixture: signature lines:list/1/str, prefixes:tuple/1/str · returned int · level recorded 2026-09-24
load_matches demo/build_demo.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · f1b49bfb18520d40 · report fixture: signature path:PosixPath/0/? · returned list · level recorded 2026-09-24
load_model_metadata demo/build_demo.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · 2effd1f8b982f74e · report fixture: signature readme_path:PosixPath/0/? · returned tuple · level recorded 2026-09-24
load_role_labels demo/build_demo.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · 62eb804824fdba32 · report fixture: signature readme_path:PosixPath/0/? · returned dict · level recorded 2026-09-24
normalize in 638 papers
census: 70 implementations from 82 papers, 51 distinct outputs across 11 buckets, one shared input per bucket
reviews/CD000510/analyze_cd000510_roles.py ran · our draft was wrong fingerprinted no licence file found · pointer only · 4ebd7f5545fabcde · report fixture: signature text:str/0/str · returned str · level recorded 2026-09-24
normalize in 638 papers
census: 70 implementations from 82 papers, 51 distinct outputs across 11 buckets, one shared input per bucket
reviews/CD005354/analyze_cd005354_roles.py ran · our draft was wrong fingerprinted no licence file found · pointer only · d6054082d8efea8b · report fixture: signature text:str/0/str · returned str · level recorded 2026-09-24
normalize in 638 papers
census: 70 implementations from 82 papers, 51 distinct outputs across 11 buckets, one shared input per bucket
reviews/CD007654/analyze_cd007654_roles.py ran · our draft was wrong fingerprinted no licence file found · pointer only · e9816484b1b198c7 · report fixture: signature text:str/0/str · returned str · level recorded 2026-09-24
normalize_text in 60 papers benchmark_tools/build_reference_indexing_from_cochrane_ris.py ran · our draft was wrong fingerprinted no licence file found · pointer only · 20c568d253ca23b7 · report fixture: signature value:str/0/str · returned str · level recorded 2026-09-24
resolve_candidate reviews/CD000510/analyze_cd000510_roles.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · c900c29ec5e5f4c2 · report fixture: signature entry:str/0/str · returned tuple · level recorded 2026-09-24
review_collection_name benchmark_tools/cochrane_review_source.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · 90f97f1529633b9d · report fixture: signature pdf:PosixPath/0/? · returned str · level recorded 2026-09-24
ris_records reviews/CD005354/analyze_cd005354_roles.py ran · our draft was wrong no licence file found · pointer only · 6eae04cab3d1e143 · report fixture: returned list · level recorded 2026-09-24
title_tokens benchmark_tools/build_reference_indexing_from_cochrane_ris.py ran · our draft was wrong fingerprinted no licence file found · pointer only · a25acaf2819e6f17 · report fixture: signature title:str/0/str · returned list · level recorded 2026-09-24
unique_preserve_order benchmark_tools/reference_indexing_schema.py ran · our draft was wrong fingerprinted no licence file found · pointer only · 9ac2ddedf8b5c895 · report fixture: signature values:list/1/str · returned list · level recorded 2026-09-24
pmids_to_pmc_info benchmark_tools/pubmed_utils.py unverified no licence file found · pointer only · e8edea7b748fea72 · report
pubmed_efetch_details benchmark_tools/pubmed_utils.py unverified no licence file found · pointer only · d300858d9f7ff348 · report
pubmed_esearch benchmark_tools/pubmed_utils.py unverified no licence file found · pointer only · c68386fb79c34681 · report
resolve_candidate reviews/CD007654/analyze_cd007654_roles.py unverified no licence file found · pointer only · e07b0c7b9ac66d23 · report
review_clustered_bootstrap_intervals figures/make_paper_figures.py unverified no licence file found · pointer only · a4f47fcd6ecf26a1 · report
zip_text reviews/CD005354/analyze_cd005354_roles.py unverified no licence file found · pointer only · cfff32b3ef1e3c4e · report

Results from the paper

The Papers with Code archive ends with its 2025-07-28 snapshot. This paper's arXiv identifier, 2608.13786, was issued in August 2026, after that date, so the archive has no leaderboard rows for it.

Report a problem or propose a change · a person checks every report against the paper or source before anything changes; decisions are listed on /corrections