{"about":{"site":"https://codewithpapers.app","non_affiliation":"Code with Papers and Syntology are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Papers with Code, Meta, or the pwc-archive mirror.","licence":"CC BY-SA 4.0","licence_url":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/legalcode","attribution":"https://codewithpapers.app/attribution","modified":"archive material modified by Syntology; see the attribution page"},"url":"/paper/arxiv-2509-19326","title":"Unveiling the Merits and Defects of LLMs in Automatic Review Generation for Scientific Papers","arxiv_id":"2509.19326","date":"2025-09-13","proceeding":"NeurIPS","authors":["Ruochi Li","Haoxuan Zhang","Edward Gehringer","Ting Xiao","Junhua Ding","Haihua Chen"],"abstract":"The surge in scientific submissions has placed increasing strain on the traditional peer-review process, prompting the exploration of large language models (LLMs) for automated review generation. While LLMs demonstrate competence in producing structured and coherent feedback, their capacity for critical reasoning, contextual grounding, and quality sensitivity remains limited. To systematically evaluate these aspects, we propose a comprehensive evaluation framework that integrates semantic similarity analysis and structured knowledge graph metrics to assess LLM-generated reviews against human-written counterparts. We construct a large-scale benchmark of 1,683 papers and 6,495 expert reviews from ICLR and NeurIPS in multiple years, and generate reviews using five LLMs. Our findings show that LLMs perform well in descriptive and affirmational content, capturing the main contributions and methodologies of the original work, with GPT-4o highlighted as an illustrative example, generating 15.74% more entities than human reviewers in the strengths section of good papers in ICLR 2025. However, they consistently underperform in identifying weaknesses, raising substantive questions, and adjusting feedback based on paper quality. GPT-4o produces 59.42% fewer entities than real reviewers in the weaknesses and increases node count by only 5.7% from good to weak papers, compared to 50% in human reviews. Similar trends are observed across all conferences, years, and models, providing empirical foundations for understanding the merits and defects of LLM-generated reviews and informing the development of future LLM-assisted reviewing tools. Data, code, and more detailed results are publicly available at https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review.","url_abs":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.19326","url_pdf":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2509.19326","source":{"archive":null,"snapshot":"2025-07-28","note":"not in the Papers with Code archive (frozen at the snapshot)","row_kind":"graph","title_abstract_authors_date":"arXiv metadata, CC0 1.0 (https://info.arxiv.org/help/license)"},"code_links":[],"tasks":[],"methods":[],"datasets_introduced":[],"methods_introduced":[],"results":[],"syntology":{"atlas_url":"https://app.syntology.ai/?focus=2509.19326","mcp":{"get_harvested_code_for_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2509.19326"}},"developers":"https://syntology.ai/developers","read_at":"2026-09-24T18:15:14+00:00","read_at_is":"when the build read Syntology's graph, not when any sample ran","claim":"Per-sample execution status on synthesized fixtures; not a correctness claim about the paper. Samples come from repositories linked to the paper, official or community; repo_kind says which.","repos":[{"mentioned_in_github":null,"is_official":null,"provenance":"deterministic:regex_extraction","mentioned_in_paper":null,"url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review","reach":{"status":"ok"}}],"summary":{"unverified":13},"by_repo_kind":{"found_in_text":{"samples":13,"ran":0,"repositories":1}},"repo_kind_vocabulary":{"official":"The archive marks this repository official for the paper","named_in_paper":"The archive records that the paper mentions this repository; it is not marked official","listed":"In the archive's code links for this paper, not marked official and not recorded as mentioned in the paper","found_in_text":"Syntology found this repository in the paper's own text; whether it is the authors' implementation is not asserted","community":"Not in the archive's code links for this paper; a community repository Syntology harvested"},"n_pointer_only_for_licence":13,"samples":[{"code_sha256_prefix":"1a97536792d3eb13","entry":"build_entity_graph","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/Knowledge_graph_construct.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/Knowledge_graph_construct.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"1a97536792d3eb13"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"e3773bf4a2383d50","entry":"clean_claude_output","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/LLMs_Generation/claude_reviewer.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/LLMs_Generation/claude_reviewer.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"e3773bf4a2383d50"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"45d6f593a97ba971","entry":"compute_graph_metrics","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/Knowledge_graph_construct.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/Knowledge_graph_construct.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"45d6f593a97ba971"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"cdeca7d08e50d4c9","entry":"detect_and_save_valley_filtered","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/KDE_filter.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/KDE_filter.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"cdeca7d08e50d4c9"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"ae7dab7cedc2de5f","entry":"download_pdf","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/Paper_download.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/Paper_download.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"ae7dab7cedc2de5f"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"b590d0ec8635293f","entry":"extract_consistent_papers","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/Paper_select.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/Paper_select.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"b590d0ec8635293f"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"9b8a96aa6d6c6af9","entry":"extract_first_json","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/LLMs_Generation/claude_reviewer.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/LLMs_Generation/claude_reviewer.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"9b8a96aa6d6c6af9"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"a8c31d52558327ef","entry":"extract_text_from_mmd","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/LLMs_Generation/gemini_reviewer.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/LLMs_Generation/gemini_reviewer.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"a8c31d52558327ef"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"72d725788f0382fa","entry":"extract_valid_json","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/LLMs_Generation/claude_reviewer.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/LLMs_Generation/claude_reviewer.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"72d725788f0382fa"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"031e5c90de7a1d47","entry":"fix_illegal_escapes","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/LLMs_Generation/gemini_reviewer.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/LLMs_Generation/gemini_reviewer.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"031e5c90de7a1d47"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"ce4b06d536998685","entry":"generate_single_review","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/LLMs_Generation/gpt_reviewer.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/LLMs_Generation/gpt_reviewer.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"ce4b06d536998685"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"a0c7393409fd0be9","entry":"load_json","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/Semantic_similarity.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/Semantic_similarity.py","link_basis":"harvester_set","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"a0c7393409fd0be9"}},{"code_sha256_prefix":"b2aa91ad1bb6d352","entry":"should_filter_question","repo":"RichardLRC/Peer-Review","repo_kind":"found_in_text","path":"Code/Knowledge_graph_construct.py","file_url":"https://github.com/RichardLRC/Peer-Review/blob/HEAD/Code/Knowledge_graph_construct.py","link_basis":"first_harvest_node","language":"python","status":"unverified","verification_level":0,"contract_check":null,"metamorphic_tier":null,"behaviour_fingerprint":false,"licence":"NONE","inline_ok":false,"mcp_get_code":{"code_sha256":"b2aa91ad1bb6d352"}}]},"arxiv_metadata":{"licence":"arXiv metadata, CC0 1.0 (https://info.arxiv.org/help/license)","fields":["title","abstract","authors","date"],"primary_category":"cs.CL","source":"arxiv_api"},"syntology_extracted_results":{"kind":"leaderboard_placements","source":"Syntology's leaderboard-shaped extractor over the paper's own arXiv-HTML tables: a model pointed at a cell, the number was read from that cell and checked against the board's metric, dataset, split and scale, and an independent check accepted the entry; not reviewed by the paper's authors or the archive's editors","extractor_model":"global.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929-v1:0","verifier_model":null,"prompt_sha":"fa63d4bb9d755694","coverage":{"sentence":"Syntology has checked 6,264 of the 9,581 papers on this site that are newer than the archive; results from the others appear after they are checked.","papers_newer_than_archive":9581,"papers_checked":6264},"entries":[],"not_placed":{"boards":0,"rejected_by_independent_check":0,"refused_by_a_rule":0,"check_did_not_answer":0,"proposed_without_a_cell":0,"declined_by_site":0}}}